Tuesday, November 9, 2010

A New Mother Earth?


            Polar bears have been an international icon in the fight against global warming. I don’t know how many TV ads I’ve seen imploring me to help save the polar bears and take part in turning around climate change. Everyone knows the bears are in trouble, but the extent is still debatable. From the image projected by the media, I actually didn’t know that there was some argument on the subject but assumed it was universally accepted that the bears are in danger of extinction. Now after reading these articles I grasp that the situation is far more complex than anything I originally thought. Under the Bush administration, polar bears were listed as threatened species under the Endangered Species Act, which they asserted could not be used to set climate policy or limit greenhouse emissions. This ruling pleased oil and gas companies and the state of Alaska, all players who pose to benefit from offshore petroleum drilling on the outer continental shelf of the Chukchi and Bearfort seas. The status of threatened does not have the power to affect climate legislation or drilling permits. Recently a federal judge from the U.S. District Court in D.C. challenged the threatened listing and has given the Interior Department a December 23rd deadline to explain why polar bears were not listed as endangered in 2008. Environmentalists and conservationists argue that the bear’s habitat is severely threatened by the melting of sea ice in large part due to global warming. The bears have been forced to dry land where they can no longer feed on their traditional prey, seals. New research shows that polar bears in Canada have instead begun to prey on snow geese. The depleting population of polar bears and/or their shift in diet will cause a significant change in the structure of arctic ecosystems.
            In my opinion, polar bears should be listed as endangered and hence be further protected by the Endangered Species Act. I realize that this might cause problems in terms of limiting offshore drilling, which in turn deepens our reliance on foreign oil, but in the long term preserving our environment is more important. The U.S. needs to place more of an emphasis on alternative sources of energy and opening up more offshore drilling will only lessen the momentum towards renewable energy sources. Perhaps more importantly, the polar bear debate brings up controversial philosophical questions: who are we to say that our survival is more important than that of the polar bear population? And when we direct natural selection, can we really justify the endangerment and extinction of other species as a “natural” consequence? I personally don’t believe that we can call the possible extinction of polar bears—or any other species for that matter—the role of natural selection when our activity is changing their environment. Humans can claim to be the new mother earth, but in the end mothers always win. (481)

No comments:

Post a Comment