Tuesday, November 9, 2010

A New Mother Earth?


            Polar bears have been an international icon in the fight against global warming. I don’t know how many TV ads I’ve seen imploring me to help save the polar bears and take part in turning around climate change. Everyone knows the bears are in trouble, but the extent is still debatable. From the image projected by the media, I actually didn’t know that there was some argument on the subject but assumed it was universally accepted that the bears are in danger of extinction. Now after reading these articles I grasp that the situation is far more complex than anything I originally thought. Under the Bush administration, polar bears were listed as threatened species under the Endangered Species Act, which they asserted could not be used to set climate policy or limit greenhouse emissions. This ruling pleased oil and gas companies and the state of Alaska, all players who pose to benefit from offshore petroleum drilling on the outer continental shelf of the Chukchi and Bearfort seas. The status of threatened does not have the power to affect climate legislation or drilling permits. Recently a federal judge from the U.S. District Court in D.C. challenged the threatened listing and has given the Interior Department a December 23rd deadline to explain why polar bears were not listed as endangered in 2008. Environmentalists and conservationists argue that the bear’s habitat is severely threatened by the melting of sea ice in large part due to global warming. The bears have been forced to dry land where they can no longer feed on their traditional prey, seals. New research shows that polar bears in Canada have instead begun to prey on snow geese. The depleting population of polar bears and/or their shift in diet will cause a significant change in the structure of arctic ecosystems.
            In my opinion, polar bears should be listed as endangered and hence be further protected by the Endangered Species Act. I realize that this might cause problems in terms of limiting offshore drilling, which in turn deepens our reliance on foreign oil, but in the long term preserving our environment is more important. The U.S. needs to place more of an emphasis on alternative sources of energy and opening up more offshore drilling will only lessen the momentum towards renewable energy sources. Perhaps more importantly, the polar bear debate brings up controversial philosophical questions: who are we to say that our survival is more important than that of the polar bear population? And when we direct natural selection, can we really justify the endangerment and extinction of other species as a “natural” consequence? I personally don’t believe that we can call the possible extinction of polar bears—or any other species for that matter—the role of natural selection when our activity is changing their environment. Humans can claim to be the new mother earth, but in the end mothers always win. (481)

Sunday, October 17, 2010

Sustainability Panel

           This most recent installment of the Spirit of the Census speakers was actually a bit disappointing for me. The panel consisted of the dean of the school of sustainability, the director of the biotechnology school, and the dean of humanities, all from ASU. With such illustirous faculty members coming to speak, I suppose I expected some more concrete discussion regarding current environmental problems and possible solutions. I was looking forward to hearing what new and innovative methods each school within ASU was pursuing in order to tackle some of these issues. However, the discussion took a different route and instead looked at the problems of population growth and human flourishing. How do we define success and what does it take for a society to flourish?
          For the dean of humanities, success means maintainging the value of human connection in modern society and technology. The profesor of biotechnology contended that we must use less resources to flourish, as people did in the 50s and 60s. Lastly, Dr. Sander van der Leeuw (from the school of sustainability) opened the discussion with an interesting viewpoint on human flourishing. Although I enjoyed the presentation and the ideas presented, especially  the "what would you do?" I was dissapointed that I didn't really come home with my imagination inspired with crazy new methods of creating electricity. As some of the foremost experts in their fields, I expected the speakers to elaborate of the current work they  do. I particularly hoped to hear more about the biofuel from algae that the school of biotechnology is currently working on. Despite these setbacks, the conversation was still fun and intellectually stimulating.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

My Environmental Worldview


            Over the past couple of weeks, I’ve really had to analyze my own thoughts regarding the environment. How should I be living in order to be more sustainable? What more should the government be implementing in the field of environmental law? What is my environmental worldview? These are all complex ideas that I’m delving more into and attempting to answer, though I’m still in the formulation stage. So far my views haven’t changed much, but I’m definitely thinking about these questions on a much higher level now. I still believe that our current way of life and economy are unsustainable and that drastic changes will have to be made in this century if human life as we know it is to continue.  I certainly don’t hold the planetary management view as my own, and never have. But how should we think of our place in the world and our duty to the environment?
            Over the past couple of weeks, I’ve decided that my viewpoints lie somewhere between the stewardship and the environmental wisdom worldviews. If we lived in an ideal world, I would be a follower of the environmental wisdom view, but since we don’t I feel that it’s better to be more practical about what we can actually achieve. I agree with most of the aspects of the wisdom view: that we are dependent on the earth’s services and that nature exists for the good of all species, not just the human race. I concur that our future success depends on better understanding nature and incorporating its lessons into our lives. However, I’m also realistic: our world is dominated by corporations and governments that are primarily focused on economic progress first and foremost, even if that progress means environmental destruction. There just isn’t a strong enough sense of urgency for environmental issues. Hence, I support aspects of the stewardship view (that we are protectors of the earth and must encourage eco-friendly development) because it seems more practical an in-line with the way our world is running at the moment. The stewardship view states that we will continue to use nonrenewable resources for our benefit, but we must use them as sustainably as possible. 
            While I like to think that shifting to a sustainable economy and lifestyle won’t be hard once we commit, I’m not sure who I want to do the committing first: me or the government? Who should be the ones leading this revolution? Personally, I’m not sure if I’m ready to completely commit, but at the same time I understand that these changes have to come from the bottom up. The government is not just going to change to a more sustainable economy without intense pressure from the people. Previously, I wasn’t as aware of how complicated the situation really is, and I’m glad that I’ve been given the opportunity to look more deeply into our current state of environmental affairs. (480)

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Gorillas Galore


          As my first exposure to the Spirit of the Census, Gorilla Encounters was a captivating presentation and a wonderful introduction to primatology and the Census series. The Steklises were engaging speakers and obviously experts in their field. I still can’t comprehend how they can have so many projects running at once! Perhaps the most charming aspect of the presentation was the obvious passion the couple shared for the subject and each other as they finished each other’s sentences and insisted that one of them could tell the story better than the other. I could really feel their zeal as they spoke about Karisoke and then Titus and Molly—two of the research station’s lovable gorillas. For me it was fascinating to learn about the similarities between humans and gorillas. I had no idea that mountainbacks omit the same odors as humans do and had their own form of tonal dialect. That the simple sounds of “ugh ugh” could mean “no, stop that” when grunted correctly by humans is amazing. The notion that gorillas have an even higher level of conversation and curiosity than we could even imagine hadn’t struck me before. I didn’t fully comprehend the innate level of humanity that all gorillas possess.
            The ongoing project with the gorilla Koko to attempt to uncover some of gorilla dialogue is particularly compelling. Asking Koko what sounds and gestures mean makes perfect sense now, though I can understand how it must have been an unusual conclusion to make at the time the Dr. H. Dieter Steklis came up with it. Possibly the best story of the night was Netzin Steklis’s conversation with Koko. It’s mind-blowing to think that a human can actually have a conversation with a gorilla. Koko asked her if the two children standing near were hers, and then if they were boys, and so on. That is incredible and only goes to show how much we don’t know about these beautiful creatures. What’s going on in their heads? What do they think about? Do they worry? Do they love? All of these riveting questions remain to be answered, but I’m confident that primatoligists are moving in the right direction. Who knows, maybe in 50 years I’ll be able to have my own conversation with a gorilla. Speculation aside, one thing that’s certain is I’ll definitely be attending more Spirit of the Census speakers in the future.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Ecological Footprints

The Ecological footprint activity was trying to be as optimistic as it could be, but I still couldn’t help feeling depressed about my footprint and the way we are treating our environment. To substantially reduce my ecological footprint I would need to do a rather wide variety of activities in tandem, such as use public transport, buy less plastic, install solar panels, use energy efficient appliances, buy fewer things in general, and fly less. While I would like to be able to do these things, I can’t make all those changes at this stage in my life (more on that in the next paragraph).While the website did a good job of informing me about the things I could be doing to live more sustainably, it still produced a negative feeling, because for me to do all of these things myself would be really difficult. In my opinion, the government needs to step in to make this transition easier. If we made more regulations on packaging to reduce the use of plastic, enforced that all new homes be more eco-friendly, subsidize or increase tax cuts for companies that manufacture eco-friendly products so as to lower their prices, and improved public transit, it would be much easier for me and other people to make a difference. Redoing the activity as a person living in Switzerland really helped me see the benefits of a more environmentally active government. Imagining that I lived in Geneva, I was able to guess that I probably used public transport most of the time (the Swiss are famous for their meticulous train/bus timing), lived in a smaller space and hence used less heating, and bought more efficient appliances in line with European Union standards (though Switzerland is not in the EU, I would assume that its people use the same products). So while the American quiz was optimistic in its attitude, it was limited in reach, not once mentioning how we can change our country and the world on a higher level. How should we as a society be trying to influence our politicians to take action?

Though it would be difficult for me to change many aspects of my life like those listed in the first paragraph, the hardest thing would be for me to buy less. I’ll admit it: I am materialistic. I don’t value goods above relationships or experiences, but I do find joy in buying clothes and gadgets, eating good food, and taking nice vacations. Unfortunately, all of these activities are at the expense of the environment. Clothes and gadgets are made in factories, which consume a lot of electricity and pollute chemicals. Eating at restaurants can also produce a lot of waste and contributes to the large-scale transportation of food. Travel can have a negative impact: plane pollution and hotel lighting, water usage, food consumption, and heating/ AC consume a large amount of resources. Most people like to buy things and I honestly don’t see this changing anytime soon. With the worldwide middle class continually expanding, materialism as an economic and cultural staple will dominate for a while yet. Trying to persuade people to buy less in today’s materialistic culture is ineffective; instead we should be putting our efforts and tax money into making what we buy sustainable.